For his part, the Witch King has passed beyond the veil of mortal concerns, but if Malekith any longer fears anything, he fears the vengeance of Alith Anar. Other High Elves scoff at such tales, but few amongst them would not wish to be proven wrong. They tell that on the darkest night of the Season of Frost, a grey-garbed figure can be seen kneeling before Eothlir's tomb, head bowed in silent contemplation of the bloody deeds the coming year will bring. The Shadow Warriors believe he still walks the world, a restless spirit of vengeance. Those of his foes who were not killed in battle were crucified upon trees, where those who passed could witness their grisly fate, and as he attacked and burned each enemy encampment, his fame grew. In those days there were many Dark Elves still hiding in Ulthuan, and Alith Anar took to their eradication with a bloody vengeance. The lord was the last heir of a great line, his forebears having been slain by the Witch King's minions. Tradition maintains that the Nagarythi chose Alith Anar as ruler after Malekith fled into the west.

Alith Anar, Prince of Nagarythe and the Shadow King is the current ruler of the Kingdom of Nargarythe and the last member of the noble line of House Anar.